Homepage

Welldoing Articles

Are We Telling Our Stories or Performing Them?

Are We Telling Our Stories or Performing Them?

Nov 16, 2026

    Psychotherapist Anna Sergent investigates how the modern world rewards constructed, inauthentic stories - and how therapy can create a space for honest narratives.

Our culture, shaped by social media posts, memes and snapshot TikTok videos, is increasingly governed by performance and visibility. We are invited to remake ourselves through what is trending now, less so through our history and the texture of our family culture. Meditation apps command us to “stay in the present,” and perhaps we took that advice quite literally.

Philosophy, literature and psychoanalysis each offer something different: a space where meaning unfolds slowly, in uncertainty and waiting, and where the story can be contradictory, partial or blurred.

From Story to Performance

Byung-Chul Han observes that contemporary culture has shifted from storytelling to something more performative. Storytelling centres the narrative rather than the narrator. In The Expulsion of the Other (2018) he writes: “The negativity of the Other now gives way to the positivity of the same.” Why value negativity when positivity feels easier to bear?

Stories once helped us discover who we were, allowing us to encounter ourselves as unfinished beings. Nowadays we often tell stories to be seen, to perform coherence rather than try to find it. Which version of me suits my career best now? What values might attract the person I’m looking for? Identity, detached from its own lived logic, is rewritten for visibility rather than grounded in lived experience.

Hemingway and the Unspoken

Hemingway’s iceberg theory captures something essential about genuine narrative: what is said is only a small part of the story; meaning lies submerged. In Big Two-Hearted River (1925), Nick Adams returns to Michigan after the war and goes fishing alone. Although the war is not directly discussed, its trauma is often understood to be present in the silences of a psyche unable to find words for the unspeakable. Nick notices every detail of his surroundings, as if these sturdy elements held him together. A familiar heaviness comes over him as he watches the trout, but he moves away from it, as if perception could take the place of reflection.

Meaning lives in slips, silences, gestures, fragments. This is also true of psychoanalytic work, where speech may arrive fragmented, defensive or performative, and the deeper narrative emerges in the gaps, repetitions and slips of the tongue.

The Psychoanalytic Space as Counterpoint

The psychoanalytic space allows a narrative to unfold without the need for certainty or approval. The work is less about helping patients fit into social narratives, and more about allowing their own narratives to emerge. Rehearsed stories give way to forgotten fragments that gradually link into a narrative that holds together in a personally meaningful way.

Olga Tokarczuk’s Flights (2007) echoes this. Recalling her psychology studies in 1980s Poland, she describes how, in animal experiments, at least one rat would always defy expectations, standing on its hind legs to look back at the experimenters, “disdaining the perks of Pavlovian conditioning.” Her experience led her to question whether the complexity of the world could be captured through simple answers to carefully framed questions. Even with expertise in statistics and knowledge of data, she suggests, we cannot fully grasp the workings of the world. “The psyche is quite a tenuous object of study.”

Why This Matters for Psychoanalytic Practice

Patients sometimes arrive with a rehearsed account, sometimes with notes of what they plan to say. This can ease the anxiety of beginning, but as the work develops, speech becomes more associative. The patient may wander, contradict themselves, or say something they had not intended. The mind begins to surprise itself.

For the analyst, this means listening to the story presented and also to its interruptions, repetitions and omissions. The task is not to distinguish a ‘real’ story from a performed one, but to stay attentive to what takes shape in speaking. What seems irrelevant may acquire significance over time.

Narration in psychoanalysis is a psychic act: a space where experience need not be immediately organised or made coherent, and where something of the patient’s own narrative can emerge, as a way of beginning to live with greater complexity, contradiction and continuity.

A Response from Gastón Tourn

There’s something about the way we tell stories in hyper-commercialised spaces that feels almost like a betrayal of the very notion of storytelling.

The communication theorist Paula Sibilia captures this cultural shift in her work The Intimacy as a Spectacle, focusing on how the digital age has redefined intimacy. No longer confined to private moments, our personal lives are increasingly performed for a global audience. But how can a sense of self truly be built when every intimate moment is publicly shared?

And yet, isn’t any narrative inherently performative? As the philosopher of language John Austin famously argued, “speech is always an act of performative utterance.” We select what to share, and we share it with someone in mind. Every story, in some way, is constructed with an audience.

So who are we telling our current stories to, and what distinguishes these performative acts from the narratives we’ve always told? Perhaps what makes storytelling in hyper-commercialised spaces so suffocating is its formulaic nature. On social media, brands and influencers alike speak endlessly about "authenticity" – yet authenticity is the opposite of a perfectly crafted story. Even stories of pain are carefully curated, leaving little sense of another human being on the other side. Social media has certainly encouraged openness around mental health, but these conversations rarely capture the nuance of lived experience. There is a formula for every story: start with controversy to hook attention, deliver a punch in the first three seconds and end with a call to action. Predictability kills the story; in storytelling, the unexpected is what brings authenticity and the suspension of disbelief.

Hemingway expressed it beautifully: “When writing a novel a writer should create living people; people, not characters. A character is a caricature.” Online, the stories we tell often leave us with caricatures – formulaic narratives far removed from the living, breathing people we long to connect with.

And while the act of storytelling will always be performative – requiring selection, always intended for others – performative does not mean formulaic. As Olga Tokarczuk reminds us in Flights, writing is “a controlled psychosis, an obsessive paranoia manacled to work completely lacking in the feather pens and bustles and Venetian masks we would ordinarily associate with it, clothed instead in a butcher’s apron and rubber boots, eviscerating knife in hand.”

Drawing on Tokarczuk, Gastón concludes poetically:

“Without feather pens, without filters, clothed instead in a butcher’s apron and rubber boots, perhaps we can finally glimpse the authenticity social media claims to prize but so rarely delivers.”


Article tags

practitioner photo

Anna Sergent

Anna Sergent is a therapist in London

Read further


darius-bashar-vzfHHasUPk0-unsplash  1 .jpg

What Story Are You Telling Yourself?

by David Brooks

AE3I1547.JPG

Healing the Wounds of Moral Distress Through Storytelling

by Lalith Wijedoru

nong-v-9pw4TKvT3po-unsplash.jpg

The Power of Storytelling in Therapy

by Laurie Castelli-Gair

patrick-tomasso-Oaqk7qqNh_c-unsplash.jpg

Be Mindful of the Story You Tell Yourself

by Natalie Kennedy

reuben-juarez-C4sxVxcXEQg-unsplash  1 .jpg

The Stories We Tell Ourselves: Do You Dare to Change Yours?

by Sandra Hilton

How-to-tell-winning-brand-stories-on-social-media.jpg

The Emotional Power of Stories in Therapy

by Christina Moutsou

welldoing logo

We are the UK’s leading therapist matching service with 40,000+ people discovering life-changing therapy through us

mental health practitioners

Sign up as a Welldoing user to claim your free Holly Health app (worth £38.99) and more

If you need emergency help or are thinking about harming yourself, contact the Samaritans on 116 123.
For emergency services phone 999 or 112.

Join over 30,000 on our newsletter

© 2013-25 by Welldoing. All Rights reserved. Cookie Policy | Privacy Policy | Terms and conditions

Visit Welldoing on XVisit Welldoing on FacebookVisit Welldoing on YouTubeVisit Welldoing on LinkedInVisit Welldoing on Instagram

© 2013-25 by Welldoing. All Rights reserved. Cookie Policy | Privacy Policy | Terms and conditions

Welldoing Ltd is a registered trademark in England and Wales. No 8614689.