Who wants a baby?
Whether or not to start a family can feel like an overwhelming decision for many couples. In recent years, when couples bring this issue to therapy, I am struck that it is most often the female partner rather than the man who is doubtful or sometimes downright opposed to having children. Women choosing to be childfree seems to be a growing trend in the UK, according to research by the Centre for Social Justice (CSJ) published earlier this year. Much of what I will be exploring in this article holds true for same sex partners, however here I will be focusing on how gendered this issue can become for heterosexual couples.
Couples who are in conflict over having children are often in a high state of anxiety, feeling that this is make or break for the relationship. The more the man tries to convince his female partner of the joys that parenthood will bring or the more he pleads or threatens to leave, the more cornered the woman feels. At this point, in the case of these couples, it can seem that the man only sees the positive side of having a family while his female partner sees only the negatives.
The "negative" partner
Women who are ambivalent about having children can feel a strong sense of injustice about the demands that motherhood will have on them as opposed to their male partners. There can be fears about the impact of pregnancy and childbirth on their bodies as well as on their identities in the work place and outside it. Women often say how “unfair” it feels and that their partners are minimising what they have to go through.
The more her partner advocates for children, the more the woman can feel that she herself is not enough and that he only wants her as a “24/7 baby machine” in the words of a popular song. Women can express anger that is not only for themselves but for previous generations of women whose sacrifice they do not want to repeat. The woman has often worked hard to establish her career and knows that her work and hopes of promotion are likely to suffer because of the demands of family life in a way that they will not for her male partner.
Women also bring anxieties about the affordability of having a family and about what sort of a world they will be bringing children into.
The "positive" partner.
The male partner also feels a sense of unfairness in that he is depending on his partner to carry their child. He is often aware of his partner’s biological clock ticking relentlessly on and describes his envy and sadness when friends announce they are pregnant. Many men say they will be happy to be a “house husband” or to share child rearing 50/50.
Reasons men give for wanting a family include the hope of repeating their own happy experience of childhood or conversely wanting to create a better childhood for their children than they had themselves. Sometimes they may talk about the pressure from parents and the wider family to produce grandchildren, especially where the cultural norm is to have a large family. They may also feel that children will be a crucial source of comfort and support in their old age.
Starting Out
In early therapy sessions the first step can be for both partners to express how hurt and angry they are feeling in a safe setting. If each of them can begin to listen without retaliating the overwhelming sense of crisis can start to subside.
Couples may not really have thought through why they do or don’t want children. Often they are surprised to discover how deeply their own upbringing and experience of family life has impacted them. The partner who wants children may feel there is a cultural or social pressure to have a family and that this is “what you do”. The “negative” partner may have suffered childhood trauma such as the early death or the desertion of a parent, or even abuse or neglect. This can result in a feeling of not knowing how to parent and a fear of repeating the past.
Seeing the other’s point of view
As the couple start to become more curious about their own and one another’s feelings their differences can feel less entrenched.
The “positive” partner may have tried to be a cheerleader, always countering the other’s doubts with a “yes but…” rather than properly acknowledging and empathising with their fears. If the woman knows that her partner can join her in feeling some loss or regret for their life before having children and that he is prepared for some of the limitations that family life will put on their relationship then she is more likely to feel that they can support one another in family life.
It can also be important for the couple to imagine what a positive and fulfilling life could look like without children. This might involve travelling, getting involved in a cause or project or planning sporting or creative activities together. Sometimes the partner who thought they wanted children may end up agreeing that this vision is more appealing than family life.
Moving Forward
There is no one outcome in couple therapy to the question of whether or not to start a family. For some couples the ability to fully explore this important step in life can help them agree to try for a baby. For others where one partner is reinforced in their conviction that they do not want children and the other strongly feels that they do, they may make the painful decision to separate. Others may decide not to have children with both partners agreeing that their relationship is the most important thing for them and knowing that there are creative ways to have a sense of growth and a feeling of hope for the future.




